17 October 2006

Rebelling To Tradition.

". . . Rich local cultures may produce great works, but few people in the United States have that kind of cultural wealth anymore. Certainly not many Catholics. The number of Americans who grew up in a profoundly Catholic setting is smaller than it ever has been before—which creates a problem for a new culture. If Catholicism is something elected rather than received, can Catholics achieve what earlier cultures did?

Their children, perhaps, will come from a thick-enough world that they can write the kind of strong Catholic novels, make the kind of strong Catholic art, prior ages knew. But in the meantime, a rebellion against rebellion doesn’t escape the problems of rebellion, and a chosen tradition is never quite the same as an inherited one. . ."

Jody Bottum in a melancholly consideration of a re-emerging Catholic Culture in America. But let us not make the perfect the enemy of the good.


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home